What is the temperament of a Sheltie vs Collie?

What is the temperament of a Sheltie vs Collie?

Shelties and Collies are two distinct breeds with unique temperaments, despite their similar appearance. Both breeds are alert herding dogs and highly intelligent. Shelties tend to be reserved with strangers, while Collies are more inclined to approach them. Shelties are known for being loyal, loving, and energetic companions, while Collies are described as intuitive, gentle, and affectionate. These breed differences in temperament make them suitable for different households and lifestyles.

Key Takeaways:

  • Shelties and Collies have distinct temperaments.
  • Shelties are reserved with strangers, while Collies are more approachable.
  • Shelties are loyal, energetic, and loving companions.
  • Collies are intuitive, gentle, and affectionate.
  • Understanding these temperament differences can help you choose the right breed for your preferences and lifestyle.

Physical and Personality Differences

When it comes to Shelties and Collies, there are distinct physical and personality differences that set them apart. One of the most noticeable disparities is their size. Shelties stand at a height of 13-16 inches at the shoulders, weighing between 15 and 25 pounds. On the other hand, Collies are larger, with females towering at 22-24 inches and weighing 50-65 pounds, while males stand at 24-26 inches and weigh 60-75 pounds.

Aside from size, Shelties and Collies also have dissimilarities in their eye shape, eye placement, and the stop (the indentation between the forehead and the nose). These physical variances contribute to the unique appearance of each breed.

Shelties have a compact and agile build, while Collies boast a more robust and majestic presence.

Personality-wise, Shelties tend to be reserved with strangers, while Collies exhibit a more approachable nature. Shelties have a natural predisposition to analyze and size up situations before taking action, whereas Collies are more likely to instinctively approach new experiences.

The reserved nature of Shelties and the gentle approach of Collies make each breed suitable for different types of households and lifestyles.

Understanding these physical and personality differences is crucial for individuals considering Shelties and Collies as potential companions. Whether you’re drawn to the smaller, reserved nature of a Sheltie or the larger, approachable nature of a Collie, both breeds offer unique traits that can make them loving and dedicated family members.

Shared Herding History

Both the Collie and the Shetland Sheepdog share a common herding history. Collies were developed in Scotland, Ireland, and England to work as herding dogs and protect and care for farm animals. The Collie’s ability to read and respond to the commands of their master made them valuable assets in herding sheep and cattle.

Similarly, the Shetland Sheepdog originated in the Shetland Islands and herded Shetland sheep in a challenging climate.

The herding heritage of both breeds is deeply ingrained in their temperaments and instincts.


In conclusion, the temperament of Shelties and Collies differ significantly, making them suitable for different households. Shelties are known for their loyalty, energy, and reserved nature with strangers, whereas Collies are intuitive, gentle, and affectionate. Understanding these temperament differences can help you make an informed decision when choosing a furry companion.

Shelties have a reserved nature with strangers, which can make them cautious and careful. On the other hand, Collies are more inclined to approach strangers, showcasing their friendly and sociable demeanor. If you prefer a dog that is more reserved and alert, a Sheltie might be the perfect fit for you.

On the personality front, Shelties are known for their loyalty and high energy levels. They are energetic companions and thrive in active households. Collies, on the other hand, are naturally intuitive and gentle, making them great family dogs known for their affectionate nature.

Ultimately, whether you decide on a Sheltie or a Collie, both breeds have the potential to become loving and dedicated family members that will bring joy and companionship to your life. Consider your lifestyle, preferences, and the specific qualities you’re looking for in a dog, and choose the breed that aligns best with your needs and expectations.

Source Links