What are the Pros and Cons of Rough Collies?

What are the pros and cons of Rough Collies?

Considering adding a Rough Collie to your family? Before making a decision, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of this beloved breed. Rough Collies, also known as Scottish or Scotch Collies, have distinct characteristics and traits that make them unique. In this article, we will explore the benefits and challenges of owning a Rough Collie and provide you with essential information to help you make an informed choice.

Key Takeaways:

  • Rough Collies are sweet-natured and polite with strangers and other pets.
  • They have moderate exercise requirements and are generally easy to train.
  • However, they can be prone to excessive barking and may have a mild stubborn streak.
  • Regular grooming is necessary, and some individuals may be hypersensitive and high-strung.
  • Proper socialization and training are important for a well-adjusted Rough Collie.

The Characteristics of Rough Collies

Rough Collies are elegant and graceful dogs that come in two coat lengths and various colors. They have a soft and sweet personality, are polite with strangers and other pets, and make good watchdogs without being aggressive.

These charming canines require only moderate exercise and are not difficult to train. Smooth Collies tend to be more athletic and agile, while Rough Collies are generally calmer and have a more laid-back demeanor.

With their striking appearance and gentle temperament, Rough Collies are beloved companions for families and individuals alike. Their elegance and politeness make them excellent pets in various social settings, while their moderate exercise needs make them suitable for individuals or families with a less active lifestyle.

Whether you choose a Smooth Collie or a Rough Collie, both types of these beautiful dogs possess the unmistakable traits and distinctive characteristics that have endeared them to dog lovers worldwide.

The Benefits of Owning a Rough Collie

Owning a Rough Collie comes with multiple advantages. These dogs have a naturally sweet-natured and gentle disposition, making them a perfect fit for families with other pets or children. Rough Collies are known for being polite and well-mannered around strangers, ensuring a peaceful and harmonious environment.

One of the unique benefits of owning a Rough Collie is their natural instinct as watchdogs. While they are not aggressive, Rough Collies possess an inherent protective nature, alerting their owners to any potential threat. This makes them excellent companions for those seeking a sense of security without compromising on their dog’s friendly demeanor.

Moreover, Rough Collies have a moderate exercise requirement, making them suitable for individuals or families with a less active lifestyle. They thrive with regular walks or play sessions, which helps keep them physically fit and mentally stimulated. These dogs love personal attention and enjoy spending quality time with their owners, making them loyal and devoted companions.

To summarize, the benefits of owning a Rough Collie include their sweet temperament, peaceful coexistence with other pets, polite behavior with strangers, natural watchdog instincts, moderate exercise requirements, and their unwavering loyalty. These qualities make Rough Collies an excellent choice for families or individuals looking for a loving and devoted canine companion.

The Challenges of Owning a Rough Collie

While there are many advantages to owning a Rough Collie, there are also some challenges to consider. It’s important to be aware of these factors before making a decision. Some of the challenges associated with owning a Rough Collie include:

Excessive Barking: Rough Collies can be prone to excessive barking, especially when they are bored or left alone for long periods. It’s important to provide them with mental stimulation and companionship to minimize this behavior.

Shyness and Fearfulness: Without proper socialization, some Rough Collies may exhibit shyness or fearfulness towards unfamiliar people or situations. Early and consistent socialization can help prevent these behaviors from developing.

Instinctive Herding Behaviors: Rough Collies have a strong herding instinct, which means they may engage in behaviors such as chasing and nipping at moving objects, including children and other pets. This behavior can be managed through training and redirection.

Regular Grooming: Rough Collies have a dense double coat that requires regular grooming. This includes frequent brushing to prevent matting and regular trimming for those with a Rough coat. Grooming can be time-consuming and may require professional help.

To overcome these challenges, it’s important to provide your Rough Collie with proper training, socialization, and grooming. By understanding and addressing these challenges, you can create a happy and fulfilling life for both you and your Rough Collie.

Temperament and Training of Rough Collies

Rough Collies are known for their soft and sweet temperament. They are sensitive dogs that thrive in peaceful environments. Frequent tension or loud voices can make them uncomfortable and stressed. To ensure their well-being, it’s essential to create a calm and harmonious home for your Rough Collie.

When it comes to training, Rough Collies generally have a mild-to-moderate stubborn streak. However, they are usually easy to train using calm and positive methods. Verbal corrections, gentle leash guidance, and a lot of praise and encouragement can go a long way in shaping their behavior. Building a strong bond based on trust and respect is crucial for successful training.

Training a Rough Collie requires patience and understanding. They respond well to positive reinforcement and gentle guidance. It’s important to avoid harsh training methods or yelling, as it can lead to anxiety and fearfulness in these sensitive dogs.

Some Rough Collies may be hypersensitive and highstrung, requiring extra patience and care during the training process. It’s important to understand their individual needs and adjust your training approach accordingly. Consistency and positive reinforcement will help them develop into well-behaved and balanced dogs.

Remember, the key to successful training is to establish yourself as a calm and confident leader. Rough Collies thrive on praise and enjoy pleasing their owners, so be sure to reward their good behavior generously.

Exercise and Mental Stimulation for Rough Collies

Rough Collies have moderate exercise needs and do not require miles of running. However, they still need regular opportunities to vent their energy and engage in interesting activities to prevent boredom. Without sufficient exercise and mental stimulation, Rough Collies may become bored and exhibit behaviors such as excessive barking and destructive chewing.

Providing daily walks and interactive play sessions can help keep them physically and mentally stimulated. Taking your Rough Collie for a walk not only provides them with essential physical exercise but also allows them to explore new scents and environments, which is mentally stimulating for them. Interactive play sessions, such as playing fetch or engaging in puzzle games, can channel their energy and provide mental stimulation.

Engaging in activities that challenge their problem-solving skills and instincts, such as obedience training and agility courses, can also be beneficial for their mental well-being. These activities not only keep them mentally sharp but also strengthen the bond between you and your Rough Collie.

“Regular exercise and mental stimulation are key for keeping Rough Collies happy and fulfilled.”

Remember to consider your Rough Collie’s individual exercise and mental stimulation needs, as some may require more or less than others. Consulting with a professional dog trainer or veterinarian can help you tailor a suitable exercise and mental stimulation plan for your Rough Collie.

Socialization and Emotional Needs of Rough Collies

Proper socialization is crucial for Rough Collies to develop a confident and well-rounded temperament. These naturally standoffish dogs need exposure to different people, sights, and sounds from an early age to prevent shyness and fearfulness. By gradually introducing them to various environments and social situations, you can help them feel more comfortable and confident in different settings.

Rough Collies are emotionally sensitive dogs and thrive in peaceful and harmonious environments. They are highly attuned to their owner’s emotions and can easily pick up on tension or stress. To ensure their emotional well-being, it’s important to provide them with a calm and stress-free home environment.

Exposing your Rough Collie to frequent tension or loud and emotional voices can have a negative impact on their emotional state. They may become unhappy and develop neurotic behaviors as a result. Creating a calm and peaceful atmosphere, free from excessive noise or intense emotions, is essential for their emotional stability.

Remember, every Rough Collie is unique, and their emotional needs may differ. It’s important to pay close attention to their body language and behavior to understand their individual needs. By providing appropriate socialization and creating a stress-free environment, you can help your Rough Collie thrive both emotionally and behaviorally.

Grooming Needs of Rough Collies

Rough Collies have specific grooming needs, particularly those with a Rough coat. Maintaining their coat requires regular brushing and combing to prevent matting and tangles. This not only keeps them looking their best, but also promotes a healthy coat and skin. Grooming sessions also provide an opportunity to bond with your Rough Collie and keep an eye out for any potential health issues.

Regular trimming is necessary for sanitary reasons, especially around the hind end to prevent feces from getting caught in the long fur. It’s important to use proper grooming tools and techniques to ensure a comfortable experience for your Rough Collie. If you’re not familiar with grooming techniques, it might be helpful to seek guidance from a professional dog groomer or attend a grooming class.

Smooth Collies, on the other hand, have a shorter coat and do not require as much combing or trimming. However, they still need regular brushing, especially during shedding seasons, to remove loose hair and maintain a healthy coat.

Grooming is an essential part of Rough Collie care, and owners should be prepared for the grooming maintenance that comes with owning this breed. Regular grooming not only helps keep your Rough Collie looking beautiful, but it also ensures their comfort and overall well-being.

Health Considerations for Rough Collies

Rough Collies, like all breeds, have potential health issues that you should be aware of. Some of the common health concerns in Rough Collies include eye diseases, skin disorders, epilepsy, and heart disease. Regular eye examinations by a veterinary ophthalmologist are recommended to detect and manage eye diseases, including progressive retinal atrophy (PRA). It’s important to monitor their health and provide regular veterinary care to ensure their well-being.

In addition to eye diseases, Rough Collies are known to have drug sensitivity, which can be a serious issue. It’s crucial to be cautious when administering medications to your Rough Collie and consult with your veterinarian to ensure their safety.

Considering a Rough Collie as a Pet

Before deciding to bring a Rough Collie into your family, there are several factors to consider. Providing enough exercise and mental stimulation, socialization, and a peaceful home environment are important for their well-being.

The potential for excessive barking, shedding, and grooming requirements should also be taken into account. Rough Collies are known for their beautiful, thick coats, which require regular brushing and maintenance to keep them healthy and tangle-free.

However, the rewards of owning a Rough Collie as a pet are numerous. They are sweet-natured, gentle, and make devoted companions. Rough Collies are known for their loyalty and bond closely with their owners.

With proper socialization and training, Rough Collies can be well-behaved and obedient. They are intelligent dogs that enjoy learning and pleasing their owners.

“Rough Collies are not only beautiful, but they are also highly intuitive and emotionally sensitive,” says Dr. Emily Wilson, a veterinarian with years of experience working with the breed. “They have an incredible ability to connect with their owners on a deep level, which can make them truly exceptional pets.”

It’s also important to note that temperament and behavior can vary among individuals. While Rough Collies are generally friendly and good-natured, some may have certain quirks or challenges that require extra attention and understanding.

By providing the right environment, training, and care, Rough Collies can thrive and become wonderful additions to families or individuals looking for a loyal and affectionate companion.


Rough Collies have both pros and cons as a breed, and deciding to own one requires careful consideration of their characteristics, needs, and potential challenges. On the positive side, Rough Collies are sweet-natured, gentle, and devoted companions. They are known for their polite behavior with strangers and other pets, making them a great choice for families or individuals seeking a peaceful home environment.

However, it is important to acknowledge the potential pitfalls. Rough Collies can be prone to excessive barking, which can be a source of frustration for some owners. Additionally, the breed has specific grooming requirements, especially for Rough-coated individuals, that demand regular maintenance. These factors should be taken into account when considering Rough Collie ownership.

Despite these challenges, Rough Collies can be wonderful additions to the right family or individual. By providing them with the proper socialization, training, exercise, and attention, you can raise a happy and well-adjusted Rough Collie. Their sweet temperament and loyalty make them a rewarding breed to own, and with the right care, they can bring joy and companionship for many years to come.

Source Links